Willa Cather, “The Namesake,” 1907
Depiction of American identity – is it innate, inherited, learnable, racial,
genetic?
What does Lyon Hartwell learn about his “American identity”? What does the
narrator learn, and what do the acolytes of Hartwell learn?
What is the significance of this group of expatriate Americans being artists –
painters, sculptors – living in Paris? Discuss the creating of American texts
from outside of America.
Cather describes Hartwell as being “from America,” from “all of it—from ocean
to ocean” (137). How does this distinguish Hartwell from those Americans who
are from a certain place? What does this say about his “nativity” – can one, in
effect, become native? Is this what he does? One can have American identity
and not know it – can be American and not know it – and it is just a matter of
unlocking the identity, this Americanness?
Consider American identity as racial, as not inheritable or learnable. Does
Michaels suggest this?
Examine the idea of discovering what it means to have a “culture.” What does
this mean? What does this have to do with finding, or appropriating (from
American Indians, from one’s dead uncle, from one’s artistic mentor), an
identity – be it racial, national, or spiritual?
What sort of idol is Hartwell’s dead uncle to him? What kind of man – or boy –
was his uncle? Was he educated? Was he hard-working? Driven? Focused?
Was he “cultured”? How does Hartwell revive his uncle by immortalizing him in
art? He makes his uncle an archetypal American, emblematic of American
struggles, freedoms, and, effectively, beautiful youth. How does this
connection with his uncle – posthumously – allow Hartwell access to the
province of American identity? Once Hartwell “has” this understanding, is it
portable? Permanent? What does this say about American identity and
whether it is or is not “place-specific” or locatable in certain places? At times
(in The Professor’s House, for example), Cather appears to suggest
that one can gaina ccess to an American past by occupying certain landscapes
and understandings the dynamics and peoples of those sites. But this is not
how Hartwell gains and sustains and American identity – or is it?
What sort of family do Hartwell and his young protégés constitute?